A machlokes among the Gaonim and the decision of the Mechaber. A question based on the gemara in Rosh Hashana. One answer. A problem with the answer based on Tosfos. A proof for Tosfos’ equating of the subjects. A second answer and a sharp dismissal of the question. A third answer based on the Ran’s answer to the Ba’al haMa’or’s question on the Rif. A fourth answer based on a new idea. A support for the idea from the gemara in Sukkah.